Chris Benoit: What If He Returned In 2022?

Okay guys, let's dive into a huge what-if scenario that wrestling fans have debated for years. What if Chris Benoit, the Canadian Crippler, somehow returned to the wrestling world in 2022? Obviously, this is purely hypothetical, given the tragic events of 2007, but it’s a fascinating thought experiment to explore the potential impact and the immense complexities surrounding such a comeback. So, buckle up, because we're about to jump into a world of wrestling fantasy, ethical considerations, and a whole lot of speculation. Let’s get into it!

The Impossibility of a Return

First, let’s address the elephant in the room. Chris Benoit's return is impossible. The tragic events of June 2007, where he murdered his wife and son before taking his own life, forever overshadow his legacy. There's no coming back from that, and rightly so. Any discussion about his return is purely hypothetical and doesn't diminish the gravity of what happened. We must always remember and acknowledge the victims and the profound impact this tragedy had on their families and the wrestling community. This isn't about glorifying or condoning his actions but rather exploring a 'what if' scenario within the context of professional wrestling. It’s a chance to examine how the wrestling landscape has changed and how a figure like Benoit might have been received in today's world, completely separate from the reality of his actions.

The Wrestling Landscape in 2022

To even begin to consider a hypothetical return, we need to understand the wrestling landscape of 2022. WWE and AEW dominate the scene, but the styles have evolved. WWE, while still emphasizing larger-than-life characters and storylines, has seen a greater appreciation for in-ring work. AEW, on the other hand, heavily emphasizes wrestling ability and caters to a fanbase that appreciates technical prowess and storytelling in the ring. Independent promotions are also thriving, showcasing diverse styles and talents from around the globe. In 2022, wrestlers like Bryan Danielson, Zack Sabre Jr., and others have popularized a more technical, grappling-heavy style – something Benoit was known for. However, the emphasis on character work and promos has also increased. Wrestlers need to connect with the audience on a personal level, telling compelling stories that resonate beyond just the moves they perform in the ring. This is an area where Benoit, while intense and believable, sometimes struggled compared to more charismatic performers.

Benoit's Style in Today's Ring

If Benoit were to step into a 2022 wrestling ring, his technical style would undoubtedly find an audience. His crisp suplexes, devastating Crippler Crossface, and overall intensity would be impressive. However, the wrestling world has become more athletic and high-flying. While Benoit was no slouch, he wasn't known for aerial maneuvers. He'd need to adapt to incorporate some more modern elements to keep up with the likes of Will Ospreay, Ricochet, and other high-flyers. But, honestly, his strength was always in his intensity and believable aggression. That would still translate. Imagine Benoit facing off against someone like Danielson. The technical exchange would be incredible. Picture him battling Jon Moxley in a brutal, no-holds-barred match. The possibilities from a wrestling standpoint are fascinating. However, the ethical and moral implications remain a massive hurdle.

The Ethical Minefield

This is where things get incredibly complicated. Even in a hypothetical scenario, the ethical considerations cannot be ignored. Would any major wrestling promotion even consider booking him? The public relations nightmare would be immense. Sponsors would likely pull out, and there would be widespread condemnation from media outlets and the general public. Some fans might be intrigued, drawn in by the controversy and the chance to see a wrestling legend. But many others would be disgusted and boycott any promotion that featured him. The moral implications are profound. Can you separate the performer from the person? Is it right to profit from someone who committed such heinous acts? These are not easy questions, and there are no simple answers. Any discussion about Benoit's return must acknowledge the pain and suffering he caused and the lasting impact on the families of the victims.

Potential Storylines (Hypothetically Speaking)

Purely from a creative standpoint, let's speculate about potential storylines. If, in some bizarre alternate reality, Benoit were to return, how could he be presented? Would he be a heel, embracing the darkness of his past? Or would he attempt a redemption arc, acknowledging his mistakes and seeking forgiveness? A heel turn could be incredibly dark and controversial. Imagine him using the Crippler Crossface as a symbol of his past, taunting opponents and reveling in the boos. This would generate massive heat, but it could also be seen as exploitative and disrespectful to the victims. A redemption storyline would be equally challenging. It would require immense sensitivity and a willingness to address the tragedy head-on. He would need to show genuine remorse and demonstrate a commitment to changing his life. This could be a powerful story, but it would also be a risky one, with the potential to backfire if not handled correctly.

Fan Reaction

The fan reaction to a Benoit return would be incredibly divided. Some hardcore wrestling fans, who appreciate his in-ring work, might be curious to see him perform again. They might argue that everyone deserves a second chance, or that it's possible to separate the art from the artist. However, the vast majority of fans would likely be repulsed. The memories of the tragedy are still fresh in many people's minds, and the idea of cheering for someone who committed such violent acts would be unthinkable. Social media would be a battleground, with heated debates and calls for boycotts. It's hard to imagine any scenario where a Benoit return wouldn't be met with widespread condemnation and protest. The wrestling world has become more aware of social issues and more sensitive to the impact of its performers' actions. In today's climate, a Benoit return would be seen as a massive step backward.

Impact on Other Wrestlers

A Benoit return would also have a significant impact on other wrestlers. Many of Benoit's peers have spoken out about the tragedy, expressing their shock, grief, and disappointment. Some have distanced themselves from him entirely, while others have acknowledged his talent but condemned his actions. Imagine being in the locker room with Benoit after what he did. The atmosphere would be incredibly tense and uncomfortable. Would wrestlers be willing to work with him? Would they feel safe sharing a ring with him? The presence of Benoit could create a toxic environment, undermining the camaraderie and trust that are essential to professional wrestling. It could also create a moral dilemma for many wrestlers, forcing them to choose between their careers and their conscience.

Conclusion: A Line That Can't Be Crossed

Ultimately, the question of whether Chris Benoit could return in 2022 is a moot point. The reality is that his actions have forever barred him from the wrestling world. While it's interesting to speculate about his potential impact on the current landscape, we must never forget the victims of his crimes and the profound damage he caused. This thought experiment serves as a reminder of the importance of accountability, the need for mental health support, and the ethical considerations that must guide our entertainment choices. Some lines simply cannot be crossed, and Chris Benoit's legacy is a stark reminder of that fact. So, while the wrestling fan in us might wonder 'what if?', the human in us knows that some things are just impossible, and for very good reason.